Welcome to Romeo & Juliet’s Caffe
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffe is a cozy culinary gem located at 5199 Sheridan Dr, Buffalo, NY. Known for its homemade dishes, the café offers exceptional portion sizes and flavors that delight every palate. Guests rave about the fresh sausage ravioli in Alfredo, mountainous mushroom and goat cheese salad, and the mouthwatering casata cake, perfect for celebrations. Fast, friendly service enhances the dining experience, making it ideal for both dining in and takeout. With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Romeo & Juliet’s Caffe is a must-visit for anyone seeking delicious Italian cuisine in a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffe: Reviews & Ratings
Great portions and great food! Whether I’m eating there or picking up takeout it’s always excellent.
I ordered a casata cake for a friend's birthday. It was so easy. I received a text about 10 minutes before my pick up time, but I called them an hour earlier than my pick up time. They said my cake was ready and to come and get it at my convenience. Fast friendly service. The cake was amazing. Everyone loved it.
Excellent hidden gem. The sausage ravioli in Alfredo was fresh, hot and a great portion size. The chardonnay was crisp, and the mushroom and goat cheese salad was MOUNTAINOUS and I'm so excited to have leftovers of it for the next day or so. For real, it was huge and light at the same time. Highly recommend (Update) still so good. Look at that MOUND of eggplant Parm!!
Honestly the service was really fast and the server was very kind. We stopped by and tried out their pizza. It was really delicious. Planning on going again sometime in the future to try their other food too.
AAAAMAZING! We had the distinct pleasure of taking our family for an early dinner for my daughter's graduation. The food is all homemade, and simply delicious. The owner waited on our table from the time we walked in. We needed for nothing. Great appetizers, wonderful meal and if you can save room, my kids loved the coffee. We will certainly be returning. Thank you for a perfect celebration!
The food was amazing. The atmosphere was absolutely perfect. The man who waited on us knew just what we needed. Do not skip on dessert either. Everything was just right!
4th time - different branch - same experience. Amazing staff and wonderful menu. Vegetarian friendly. Tried something different this time that has to do with eggplants bruschetta.
Great place and fantastic service. The food was so fresh and live the olive tapanade served with the bread to start. A definite repeat visit to this great establishment.
Location
-
5199 Sheridan Dr, Buffalo, NY 14221, United States Hotline: +1 716-839-4960
Welcome to Romeo & Juliet’s Caffe, a culinary gem located in the heart of Buffalo, New York, at 5199 Sheridan Drive. This delightful cafe captures the essence of homemade Italian cooking, combining rich flavors with an inviting atmosphere that feels like a warm embrace. From the moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly made dishes tempts your senses, making you feel right at home.
What truly sets Romeo & Juliet’s Caffe apart is not just the food, but the experience. Patrons rave about the generous portion sizes, ensuring that whether you dine in or opt for takeout, you leave fully satisfied. Take, for instance, Megan Mc's endorsement, celebrating the consistently excellent cuisine that keeps her coming back time and again.
The menu boasts a variety of dishes that reflect the warmth of Italian hospitality. The sausage ravioli in Alfredo shines brightly, described by Jillian Straw as “fresh” and “hot,” making it a must-try for pasta lovers. Pair it with a crisp Chardonnay and you're in for a delightful treat. For those seeking something lighter, the mushroom and goat cheese salad offers the perfect balance of flavors, with its mountainous serving ensuring you’ll savor every bite long after your meal.
Service at Romeo & Juliet’s Caffe is nothing short of exceptional. Guests like Fran Testa appreciate the friendly staff and the seamless experience, from ordering a special birthday cake to enjoying a quick meal. The personal touch of having the owner attend to guests amplifies the warm atmosphere, making every visit special.
And let’s not overlook the pizza—a fan favorite, loved for its delightful taste and perfect crust, as noted by Lynn Kegg. It's the kind of dish that invites you to linger a little longer, sharing stories and laughter over a delicious meal.
For celebrations big and small, Peggy Pozzuto highlights the cafe's ability to turn moments into memories with their homemade food. Whether it’s a graduation dinner or a simple family outing, each dish comes infused with love and attention to detail. Romeo & Juliet’s Caffe is not just a place to eat; it’s a destination for connection, celebration, and comfort.
So, whether you’re a local or just passing through Buffalo, make sure to experience the magic of Romeo & Juliet’s Caffe. It's where food becomes an art, and every meal is a story waiting to be told.